Add-on Collector: a potentially awesome Firefox feature that falls short
Jed | January 31, 2010I’ve recently been playing around with Firefox’s Add-on Collector, and I have to say it could be really useful but currently it fails to deliver on its potential.
Here’s how Mozilla describes the Add-on Collector:
Discover more of the best add-ons and organize your favorites in easy-to-manage collections. Subscribe to see how the collections you admire grow, and fans follow when you manage and update your own collections.
At first, I assumed this meant I could subscribe to lists (aka collections) of Firefox add-ons and have changes to those collections pushed to me. The truth is that it only half works like that.
Yes you can subscribe to collections of add-ons. And yes you will be notified when those collections change. So far so good. But the Add-On Collector provides no way for you to easily install all the add-ons from a collection. You still have to install each add-on one by one, manually. It even asks you to restart after each one (hint: you can wait until you’ve installed all of them before restarting).
I assume Mozilla didn’t think installing add-ons automatically was a good idea for security reasons. Imagine if the publisher of a popular collection quietly added a “Steal all your info” add-on to the list and then cackled as all his subscribers’ browsers auto-installed it. So it makes sense that the Add-On Collector doesn’t auto-install add-ons. But there’s not even a button to “Install All” when you subscribe to a collection (or “Remove All” when unsubscribing). Subscribing to a collection just shows you the list of add-ons and it’s up to you to go install them or not.
In addition, you have to register for a Mozilla account in order to add or manage subscriptions. Your subscriptions are stored on Mozilla’s servers. There’s no option to keep everything local on your machine. This isn’t a big deal, but it’s kind of a pain. Ideally after installing the Add-On Collector I could just start using it immediately without jumping through more hoops.
Overall, I’m a little disappointed in the Add-On Collector but it’s still better than nothing. It’s not an end-to-end solution for add-on installation and management. But once you have a Mozilla account (and remember to log in), it’s great for add-on discovery and for organizing your favorite add-ons.
You can install the Add-on Collector (which is itself a Firefox Add-on) from this page.
Once it’s installed, check out my “Can’t Browse Without” collection of add-ons. Or browse other popular collections.






